By Philip Pfanstiel
“And the peace of God, which surpasses all understanding, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus.” Philippians 4:7 ESV
“And let the peace of Christ rule in your hearts, to which indeed you were called in one body. And be thankful.” Colossians 3:15 ESV
“Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding. In all thy ways acknowledge him, and he shall direct thy paths.” KJV Proverbs 3:5-6
Peace is a curious thing. You can fake many emotions, but faking peace is just De Amazon. De Nile?
Real peace is not something you can manufacture. Fake or false peace yes, but real peace has an otherworldly quality to it. False peace can be very dangerous, and I’ll come back to it shortly, but first the real thing.
Recently, someone said I seemed to be at peace. I looked around to see who they were talking to but did so in a cool, nonchalant sort of way … since I was the one at peace.
Surreal moment.
Since we can’t fake peace and yet, as the verses above reference, we are to let peace guard our hearts and minds, and rule – how exactly do we do that?
Not being one who has arrived, I can only relate my journey. I think what we CAN do is prepare a place for peace.
That would be a good title. But wouldn’t it give away the reveal? Nah, no one will see it coming. Besides … QUIET! They’re onto us. Shouldn’t each voice have its own paragraph with quotation marks? Not you again! Simmer down you four, Nurse Ratched is coming!
It seems to me that since we can’t fake peace and yet the voices creating chaos in our lives need to be reigned in, the best we can do is prepare the table and welcome peace when it arrives.
“If you build it, they will come.”
So how to prepare a place that peace will want to frequent?
The first step is to walk in obedience. Fun little trick: ask God where you are disobedient and then pay attention to the first thought that your brain defends and rationalizes. “Dat’s a bingo!”
In hiking parlance, they talk about following the trail markers (nowadays fluorescent tape or spray paint on trees) and when you haven’t seen one for a while, back track until you see them again. That’s where you lost the plot. I prefer my metaphors shaken and stirred. Biblically and in my experience, God doesn’t often change His call or assignment. Real peace is found when we seek Him fully and surrender all of our plans and say, “Here am I, send me.”
Obedience. This is the foundation for peace. The challenge I received from God over a decade ago was to write down and recount “What has God said?” I return to this growing list of words, dreams, “coincidences,” and scriptures that have all hit and continue to resonate with me. While family and friends will give their best counsel, we know on a deep level what God is speaking to us, and it is these directions … “to thine own self be true.” Taking seriously and trying to walk out the things God has communicated to you is the first step for welcoming peace.
I find the most ironic confirmation that one is hearing God is when He corrects you. God corrects those He loves (Hebrews 12:6-8). I’ve been corrected many times over the years, and while not pleasant (sometimes very unpleasant) I find a glimpse of peace in these corrections. They mean that 1.) God hasn’t given up on me, 2.) I’m not so hardened that I resist or miss the correction, and 3.) Those areas He’s not correcting me on … there’s a chance I’m not completely crazy. 😊
Prayer and praise are no brainers, but I’ve been challenged to pray in tongues more. It also is great for arresting anxious thoughts, dark moments, and the like. Singing a praise song or praying in tongues are both great redirections that steer the ship away from the rocky shores and back into the peaceful flow of God’s current.
Praise or a spirit of gratitude has many other positive benefits. I read a meme or quote recently (sometimes doom scrolling can be helpful) that said, “you can’t be grateful and complain at the same time.” That challenged me like few other thoughts have, and now I share it with you. You’re welcome.
The third idea is to “Put yourself in position.” Years ago, I was in a tough place and feeling sorry for myself. A friend invited me to join him at a baseball game. I felt foolish and nearly didn’t go. I heard “put yourself in position” so I went and had an amazing night. I’ve followed that advice many times since when awkwardness, hesitancy, uncertainty, or feeling stupid try to keep me stuck.
In baseball they call it ready position. If you’re in the game you face the plate, eyes alert, glove ready, knees bent and ready for action. Life, like baseball, happens fast, and if we’re not in position, we could miss it.
To Review: Preparing a place for peace means …
Obeying what you feel God has told you. I’d rather fail trying to obey God, than fail to try.
Developing habits of praise and prayer to help renew your mind and take unwanted thoughts captive.
Put yourself in position. If you want to catch fish, a boat, pier, or the water’s edge are great places. Plopping down in the angler section at Bass Pro has all of the right answers (gear) but none of the pisces.
Real World examples of getting it right and wrong
Shalom “Phill’ed” House
Three years ago I was looking to buy my first house since the divorce. I had so many things I couldn’t reconcile, and while I kept moving forward I had a strong feeling that I was missing God. I even put an offer on a house, it was accepted, and I put $5,000 down. Then the fear hit me, “What if I’m missing God?”
I got free one day, went to a nearby lake to be alone with God. Started by surrendering everything to God and was even willing to walk away and lose the $5,000 if this wasn’t the right house. Did a pro-con list that I so love. Writing things out does something for my clarity. Suddenly is the best word I can use because not even 30 minutes alone at the secluded spot on the lake the peace hit me. It wasn’t me, because I still had questions and concerns, but the peace of God that surpasses all understanding hit me, and I got the green light and blessing to move forward.
I bought and have been living in that house with my kids for the last 30 months. It’s got space for everyone and has been a tremendous blessing, great place to host friends and family and our pack of dogs. I even find time to write missives like this one.
I’ve thought about this a lot because I could have gone forward and ignored the feeling that I was missing God and ended up in the same house. Sorta. It would have been the same house physically, but I feel God’s peace, and provision here AFTER I surrendered it to God and He blessed and gave it back to me.
Lack of Peace Warning Headed
Being warned by a lack of peace probably saved three of my kids’ lives. At my son Gabe’s graduation recently, his mom, Tamara, and I recounted the circumstances of his older brother Luke’s birth. Basically, Tamara had wanted to avoid a c-section, and when it came time to give birth the doctor offered to try inducing, and then we could pivot to a c-section if things didn’t go well. But neither of us had peace about inducing labor for a natural birth.
I knew this was especially difficult for Tamara but to her great credit she was led by peace and we chose to do a scheduled c-section. During the c-section the doctor encountered a lot of scar tissue but since it wasn’t rushed it was dealt with effectively. Then when the doctor got to Luke it was discovered that not only was the umbilical cord wrapped around his body and neck multiple times, but there was a big knot in the cord.
BUT … since peace had led us to do the c-section all of this was addressed (and allowed for two more pregnancies), and Luke has been a healthy, kind, intelligent, and enthusiastic young man who just finished his first year of college.
Going against the peace could have led to a distressed labor, emergency c-section and cut off oxygen during birth which could have left Luke with cerebral palsy or killed him or both him and his mother.
No bueno.
It was recounted at Gabe’s graduation because if that had played out differently there is a good chance that neither Gabe nor his little sister Leah would be with us today.
I’ve used this story many times when I counsel people to be led by peace. I am beyond thankful that we listened and were ruled by peace.
False or Rationalized Peace
I wish I could say I have always been ruled by peace but sometimes we learn more from when we foul it up. Ergo false peace or the false sense of safety we get from rationalization. You are welcome to learn the easy way from my epic fumbles.
My daughter Abby visited some friends years ago in OKC. I planned to rendezvous with the friend’s mother on Tuesday and bring Abby back home. That Tuesday I felt very strongly that I should pick her up but was persuaded to give her one more day with her friend. My eldest daughter Anna was upset and felt we should go get her but chalked it up to being mad. Abby later recounted that she too felt that she should come home on Tuesday.
None of us listened and that Wednesday, on the way to meet halfway, the car Abby was in ran a stop sign and was t-boned on an Oklahoma country road. The car struck right where Abby was sitting. 17 broken bones, injuries and gashes across her body could have killed her. An emergency helicopter ride to the OU hospital in OKC, multiple blood transfusions, and God’s overwhelming mercy kept her alive. Anna and I got to her right as she was waking up and caught Abby flirting with the plastic surgeon, she called Captain America, sewing up her face. Her mom arrived later that evening to nurse her back to health.
After the fact as we compared notes we all realized that God had been warning us, and even though we missed it, God’s hand was still there doing a Romans 8:28.
Being Reasonable Comes at Great Cost
Another time I felt God leading me to hire a certain high-priced consultant. I, in my infinite foolishness, hired the cheaper “Christian” consultant. Bad idea. After doing so my conscience kept reminding me of what the peace of God had told me. But every thought was dismissed and rationalized away. I was being prudent. Reasonable. Wise.
My “prudency” in disobeying the still small voice ended up costing me over 10 times as much, and took me to the darkest moment of my life … but on the bright side, it gave me another story confirming the need for being led by God’s peace and not leaning on my logic or reason. #alwayswinning
Not being led by peace nearly cost me my daughter (and who knows how much more would have been lost in the aftermath) and took me to the ledge. These mistakes of ignoring warnings, false “rationalized” peace, and not waiting for real peace are the shadows that prove the sunshine. It seems many of us learn more when we miss it. But do we want encores?
My prayer is that God would help me make new mistakes. I don’t mind eating humble pie, but I do like variety.
* * *
Ruled by Peace
I have a lot of dreams, and I don’t pretend to understand all of them, but I do take them seriously and look for patterns and unique things.
In one dream, a lady named Fredericka shows up in the co-pilot seat of the massive white passenger van I’m driving with my kids. I don’t know anyone named Fredericka. Then a lady I’m intrigued by shows up in the dream and asks Fredericka to let her sit there instead. Fredericka agrees and gets out of the van giving the seat to this other lady.
Having been single for over a decade, a dream with gorgeous women fighting over who gets to be the co-pilot with me is not a dream I’d forget.
Anyway, when I wake up, and after getting over the fact it was just a dream, I ask why Fredericka? Why that oddly specific name?
I looked it up and Fredericka means “ruled by peace.” Even my basic dream interpretation skills are honed enough to get the message.
* * *
Choosing Irrational Peace versus Comfortable Thinking
Not all peaces are created equal. The peace God offers can be overruled. As I confessed, I have done this. The peace leads me one way, but logic, convention, “what makes sense,” and the desire to not rock the boat collude to help override the peace. The times I’ve done that I, and those I love, have paid dearly for it.
But that is the trick. God doesn’t force His peace. He offers it and we can choose to let it rule, let it guard our hearts, let it guide our paths or we can choose the path more traveled and lean on our own understanding.
Just remember the lesson, so the next time you come to that divergence in the road you choose wisely and don’t fork it up again.
Make new mistakes, forge new paths, say yes to the adventure, follow the peace of God, and enjoy the places you will go.
Shalom Shalom (God’s Perfect Peace be with you)


















